Hope finally seen again
June 19, 2010 – 10:26 PM CDT
After missing little Hope several times due to her irregular visits to the feeding site, we connected with her there tonight about 9 PM after an hour wait. She is fine. Interestingly, Lily still has not been back to that area since the breakup 18 days ago. Picture at right was captured by the trail camera yesterday.
There has been a lot of discussion and opinions about what we should have done with Hope. Some newspapers have been critical, depending upon their ideas of how research should be conducted. Our usual approach of simple observational science has ranked our research one of the four major studies of large mammals in the world. It has enabled us to senior-author more peer reviewed scientific papers on black bears than anyone else. Two of those papers were ranked by bear researchers and managers around the world as being in the top five most useful publications on bears ever written. Nevertheless, a couple years ago we were officially criticized for not going beyond observation. We were criticized for not delving into experimentation and hypothesis testing like most researchers do. Now, the separation of Lily and Hope has not only offered us that opportunity but required us to do exactly that to better understand their behavior, and we are criticized for intervening and saving Hope’s life. We know we can’t please all the people all the time. We work to do what we judge to be the best for the bears and what will best fill unknowns in the scientific literature based on our 44 years of research experience.
New situations sometimes require new methods to learn new things. We feel that the course we are following with Hope is the best for science and for her.
We heard the loud cry to let nature take its course and let Hope die. We rejected that from a scientific standpoint because we wouldn’t have learned anything we didn’t already know.
We heard the cry to place Hope in a rehab facility or give her a home in the Bear Center. From a monetary standpoint, putting Hope in the Bear Center would have drawn big crowds. But that’s not what drives our research decisions. Hope in captivity would have taught us very little.
As we see how things are working out, we are very happy we chose to give Hope a temporary hand so she can live in the wild. That is where she can best fill unknowns in the scientific literature. Already, she is helping us understand the separation. Eventually, she should answer scientific questions about nature versus nurture as it pertains to diet, denning, developing social relations, and establishing a territory. Or, a totally different scenario is possible. Lily and Hope could re-unite, hibernate together, and provide an explanation for the mixed-age litters that are reported. Lily will likely have cubs this winter.
Hope may be in the process of showing us something that can help other orphans. Typically, orphans too young to survive are placed in captivity, fed for a year, and then released back into the wild. But might orphans have a better chance of learning wild ways if they are left in the wild—aided only by temporary supplements until they can find wild foods? We’re testing that by temporarily supplying formula, grapes, nuts, and mealworms. Already, she is switching to wild foods and scent-marking her area as if to establish ownership. We hesitate to speak too soon, but it seems to be working. We do wish she would keep to a more regular schedule of visiting the feeding site so we could be there to gain her trust and radio-collar her. But it is also nice to see her behaving independently, ranging up to a mile and a quarter and depositing droppings filled with remains of wild foods.
Nothing a person can do is totally right or wrong. We can only wait and see how things turn out. Was it right to give Hope a hand? Her life will provide the final answer.
Thank you for your continued support of our research and educational efforts.
—Lynn Rogers and Sue Mansfield, Biologists, North American Bear Center
_________________ memory challenged photographer owned by cats Pat
|